Fhwa life cycle cost analysis software

Additional detail on this entire process and its application are provided in the attached references, primarily in the life cycle cost analysis primer fhwa 2002a and in nchrp report 483. Nov 27, 2018 acpas 2nd vice chairman jim mack cemex and leif wathne met with fhwa officials last week to discuss life cycle cost analysis lcca. States lifecycle cost analysis practices vary, though they are often informed by fhwa guidance 9 fhwa lcca guidance aligns with about half of the costestimating best practices 15 conclusions 23 recommendation 24 agency comments 24 appendix i objec tives, scope, and methodology 25 appendix ii gao contact and staff acknowledgments 29 tables. It takes into account all costs of acquiring, owning, and disposing of a building or building system. The apa has developed life cycle cost analysis software that uses the principles recommended by the federal highway administration fhwa to compare the economics of. Highwayrail crossing handbook third edition safety. The fhwa report fhwasa98079, lifecycle cost analysis in pavement design defines lifecycle cost analysis lcca as. Jun 12, 20 furthermore, state agencies used different criteria to decide if lcca results clearly indicated a pavement type with the lowest lifecycle cost. Calculate the life cycle cost and benefit cost ratio using the hec17 approach.

Life cycle cost analysis lcca is an analytical framework to assess the most economically prudent investment from a set of alternatives. Lifecycle cost analysis an overview sciencedirect topics. New software expertly analyzes lifecycle costs of pavements. Fhwa this article is a followup to the article titled map21 and bridge lifecycle cost analysis published in the summer 20 issue of aspire.

Calculation requires sound knowledge of how the asset finds use, the various costs involved through its lifetime, and the application of economic analysis techniques to determine the present value of such future expenses. The determination of life cycle costs of alternative pavement types is an important. Conducting a benefit cost analysis bca for one or more rwm strategies can be accomplished with the support of several available software. It is essential for highway agencies to utilise tools and approaches that facilitate proper decisionmaking by applying economics and operations research such as life cycle cost analysis. Life cycle cost analysis for management of highway assets documents the state of the practice of life cycle cost analysis lcca and riskbased analysis into state highway agencies asset management plans for pavements and bridges on the national highway system. This allows for comparison of different project alternatives that will provide similar utility. Lifecycle cost analysis life cycle cost analysis lcca an economic analysis tool useful in comparing the relative economic merits of competing construction and rehabilitation design alternatives for a single project. Software from the apa is making life easier for engineers who perform lifecycle cost analysis lcca for pavements.

It describes the fundamentals of lcca and its calculation methods. Road weather management benefit cost analysis compendium chapter 3. These best practices are outlined in the fhwa s lifecycle cost analysis primer. Methods for evaluating candidate alternatives, utility cost analysis and benefit cost analysis. The method is computation intensive and ideally suited to a spreadsheet. The user cost per hour values are based on federal highway administration fhwa publication number fhwa sa98079, life cycle cost analysis in pavement design. This project will also incorporate them in realcost life cycle cost analysis lcca software so both the economical and environmental considerations can be evaluated simultaneously and together in the decision making process. Lccaexpress is a simplified version of the apas original lcca software. The tool considers crashes, vehicular delay, emissions, operations and maintenance, and capital costs. This method for calculating user costs compares traffic demand to roadway capacity on an hourbyhour basis, revealing the resulting traffic conditions.

Transportation systems management and operations benefit cost analysis compendium chapter 4. An appropriate and nonbiased method for life cycle cost analysis is articulated by the federal highway administration fhwa in demonstration project no. It is essential for highway agencies to utilise tools and approaches that facilitate proper decisionmaking by applying economics and operations research such as life cycle cost analysis lcca to achieve economically reasonable longterm investments. In 9 of the states that used lcca, fhwa s lcca guidance was an important influence on state practices, according to state transportation officials, and 7 states used lcca software developed by fhwa. Benefit cost analysis bca of one or more transportation systems management and operations tsmo strategies can be conducted with the support of several available software. Fhwa s pavement and materials research is carried out as an integral part of fhwa. Per fhwa s life cycle cost analysis primer 1, life cycle cost analysis lcca is an evaluation technique applicable for the consideration of certain transportation investment decisions. Apa releases new lifecycle cost analysis software asphalt. Pdf life cycle cost analysis as a decision support tool for. Add the cost to develop and construct the alternative. Software university of california pavement research center. Representing fhwa were latoya johnson, fhwa team leaderpavement design and performance. Aldot currently utilizes the npv method for conducting a life cycle cost analysis.

Download the spreadsheets for calculating the life cycle cost. Life cycle cost analysis cradle to grave economics. The software, available free from the asphalt pavement alliance apa, uses the principles recommended by the federal highway administration fhwa. The software, available free from the asphalt pavement alliance apa, uses the principles recommended by the federal highway administration fhwa to compare the economics of alternative designs for a given road project. To improve the cost effectiveness of its building and renovation programs, stanford must invest in designs and systems with improved longterm performance. Mtq has used life cycle cost analysis since the mid 1990s. The determination of life cycle costs of alternative pavement types is an important part of a rational means for decision making.

The fhwa recommends the net present value npv method for performing a lcca. As such, it is important for each agency to conduct a realistic assessment of pavement economics in order to provide objective input into the life cycle cost analysis. This article describes the project level, life cycle cost analysis. Lifecycle cost analysis for management of highway assets. This software can be downloaded for free from net present value method. Life cycle cost washington asphalt pavement association. Incorporate sustainability factors in the selection. The federal highway administration fhwa believes that lifecycle cost analysis lcca can help transportation agencies with this process. The fhwa blcca software tool is a powerful tool for performing various levels of project cost analysis and comparative studies. Lcca can best be summarized by two paragraphs from walls and smith 1998. Lifecycle cost analysis software lcca life cycle cost.

Life cycle cost analysis for pavement selection 3 with a probabilistic approach, input values to the analysis are defined as a range of values and their probability of occurrence. A simplified sketch of how the net present value method of life cycle cost analysis works is shown in the graphic. The pavement research center designs, develops and maintains various reseach class software applications used to assist in performing. Other enhancements made to the software included improved graphics, enhanced reporting of analysis. Lifecycle cost analysis life cycle cost analysis design. Specifically, when it has been decided that a project will be implemented, lcca will assist in determining the best the lowest cost. Fhwa promotes lifecycle cost analysis lcca as an engineering economic analysis tool that allows transportation officials to quantify the differential costs of alternative investment options for a given.

A 50year analysis period is used, and discount rates between 4 and 6 percent are considered. Transportation research board executive committee 2002 membership as. What software or program is used to perform an lcca. This project will also incorporate them in realcost life cycle cost analysis lcca software so both the economical and environmental considerations can be evaluated simultaneously and together in the. The designer must choose between using nominal dollars or real dollars when performing a lifecycle cost analysis via the npv. To those interested in including these components, the fhwa realcost realcost, lifecycle cost analysis software, version 2. Benefit cost analysis a benefit cost analysis, or bca, attempts to capture all benefits and costs accruing to society from a project or course of action, regardless of which particular party realizes the benefits or costs, or the form these benefits and costs take. The lcca process is performed by summing up the discounted monetary equivalency of all benefits and costs. Benefit cost analysis a benefit cost analysis, or bca, attempts to capture all benefits and costs accruing to society from a project or course of action, regardless of which particular party realizes the benefits or costs, or the form these benefits and costs. Pdf evaluation of pavement life cycle cost analysis. Fhwa using bridge lifecycle cost analysis tools for map21. A life cycle cost analysis lcca is a method to assess total cost of ownership, considering all costs associated with acquiring, owning, and disposing of an asset. Improving transportation investment decisions through life. Currently, the michigan department of transportation mdot updates these costs yearly using the cpi, which follows the same methodology as detailed in the fhwa.

Stochastic lifecycle cost analysis for pavement preservation. Thank you for your interest in the fhwa s pavement design life cycle cost analysis software product. Onsite realcost life cycle cost analysis lcca software workshop resources. The asphalt pavement alliance has developed software capable of performing lifecycle cost analysis using the fhwa procedure. Lcca is an engineering economic analysis tool that allows transportation officials to quantify the differential costs of alternative investment options for a given project. Need for signal coordination and off line signal timing software. Pdf life cycle cost analysis as a decision support tool. In 1998, fhwa produced demonstration project 115, life cycle cost analysis in pavement design, which developed a technical bulletin, an lcca instructional workshop, and a proof of concept for an lcca software. Nchrp project 3110, estimating the life cycle cost of intersection designs, produced a spreadsheetbased tool that supports the comparison of life cycle costs of alternative designs for new and existing intersections.

Life cycle cost analysis life cycle cost analysis tashia j. Lifecycle cost analysis lcca the apa has developed lifecycle cost analysis software that uses the principles recommended by the federal highway administration fhwa to compare the economics of alternative designs for a given road project. The designer must choose between using nominal dollars or real dollars when performing a life cycle cost analysis. The use of lifecycle cost analysis lcca as a decisionmaking tool in pavement design and the analysis of competing alternatives is recommended by fhwa.

The new software, called lccaexpress, uses the principles recommended by the federal highway administration fhwa to compare the economics of alternative designs for a given road project. Life cycle cost analysis lcca is an indispensable technique that employs wellestablished principles of economic analyses to evaluate long term performance of competing investment options. Bridge life cycle cost analysis national cooperative highway research nchrp program report 483. Developed by nist, bridge lifecycle cost bridgelcc is software with an easytouse interface that enables designers to view the lifecycle costs for project alternatives from different perspectives, such as that of cost holders the person or agency that pays the cost directly or indirectly, bridge components, application of new technologies, and cost timeline. To those interested in including these components, the fhwa realcost realcost, life cycle cost analysis software, version 2. This paper assesses the use of life cycle cost analysis lcca as a decision support tool for managing municipal infrastructure. Life cycle costs of the devices should be used, such as both installation and maintenance costs. Fhwa promotes lifecycle cost analysis lcca as an engineering economic analysis tool that allows transportation officials to quantify the differential costs of alternative investment options for a given project. Life cycle cost analysis lcca is a method for assessing the total cost of facility ownership.

Transportation systems management and operations benefit. The federal highway administration fhwa in demonstration project no. Contains free lcca software and access to fhwa report fhwa sa98079, lifecycle cost analysis in pavement design. Work zone road user costs concepts and applications. Life cycle cost analysis for indot pavement design procedures. Adjustments to pavement lifecycle cost analysis procedures. Highway administration fhwa bridge lifecycle cost analysis blcca software tool. This article describes the projectlevel, lifecycle cost analysis using the federal highway administration fhwa bridge lifecycle cost analysis blcca software tool. The asphalt pavement alliance apa has released new software for lifecycle cost analysis lcca of pavements. The lcca process is performed by summing up the discounted monetary equivalency of all benefits and costs that are expected to be incurred in each option. Although this user manual provides a working knowledge of realcost, these related documents, particularly the technical. Review and analysis article pdf available in international journal of pavement research and technology 94 august 2016 with 2,057 reads.

These best practices are outlined in the fhwas lifecycle cost analysis primer. Aldot currently utilizes the npv method for conducting a lifecycle cost analysis. Other enhancements made to the software included improved graphics, enhanced reporting of analysis results, and capability to simultaneously carry out. The new software, called lccaexpress, uses the principles recommended by the federal highway administration fhwa.

It is caltrans policy that life cycle cost impacts are fully taken into account when making projectlevel decisions for pavements. Pavexpress allows users to design pavement structures according to aashto 9398 design formulae, as well as to conduct additional analysis and comparison of projects, including lifecycle cost analysis. Thank you for your interest in the fhwa s pavement design lifecycle cost analysis software product. Joint transportation research program, indiana department of transportation and purdue university, west lafayette, indiana, 2005.

Nowadays, highway pavement construction, maintenance and rehabilitation costs are rising dramatically. An example illustrates application of the tool to compare the lifecycle costs for rehabilitation versus replacement of a bridge. Acpas 2nd vice chairman jim mack cemex and leif wathne met with fhwa officials last week to discuss life cycle cost analysis lcca. An appropriate and nonbiased method for lifecycle cost analysis is articulated by the federal highway administration fhwa in demonstration project no. Life cycle cost analysis for management of highway assets documents the state of the practice of life cycle cost analysis lcca and riskbased analysis. Life cycle cost analysis is an assessment method for estimating the performance of materials and services considering their impact on environment, from extraction of raw materials to the endof life disposalrecycling stage. The pavexpress suite of pavement design tools includes an lcca module based on fhwa s realcost lcca tool. The software automates fhwas work zone user cost calculation method.

Ror, break even analysis, and benefit cost bc ratios. Ror, break even analysis, and benefitcost bc ratios. Fhwa and was chosen by caltrans as the official software for evaluating the long term cost effectiveness of alternative designs for new and existing pavements. Incorporate sustainability factors in the selection process. Lcca can be used to study either new construction projects or to examine preservation strategies for existing transportation assets. Joint transportation research program, indiana department of. Trbs national cooperative highway research program nchrp synthesis 494. This software provides a tool to perform lcca for pavement selection in accordance with fhwa best practice methods. The apa has software conforming to fhwa procedures available for free download. Lcca is especially useful when project alternatives that fulfill the same performance requirements, but differ with respect to initial costs and. Additional details on some of the bca activities and processes can be found in the federal highway administration fhwa life cycle cost analysis primer and the fhwa operations benefit cost analysis desk reference. Developed by nist, bridge life cycle cost bridgelcc is software with an easytouse interface that enables designers to view the life cycle costs for project alternatives from different perspectives, such as that of cost holders the person or agency that pays the cost. A life cycle cost analysis is an approach to economic analysis that attempts to take all of the costs associated with a given project and convert them into a single value.

Read lifecycle cost analysis for management of highway. The asphalt pavement alliance apa has released new software for life cycle cost analysis lcca of pavements. The determination of lifecycle costs of alternative pavement types is an important part of a rational means for decision making. The software estimates the agency and user costs associated with a given pavement design and preservation strategy over the entire life cycle of the pavement.

Lcca accounts for relevant costs to the sponsoring agency, owner, operator of the facility, and the roadway user that will occur throughout the life of an alternative. This software provides a tool to perform lcca for pavement selection in accordance with fhwa. Transportation research board executive committee 2002 membership as of november 2002. Then, through simulation, output cost is expressed as ranges of values, also with probabilities of occurrence. The fhwa highway safety benefit cost analysis guide 43 and companion highway safety benefit cost analysis tool. Road weather management benefit cost analysis compendium.

1088 829 780 113 615 1168 1355 370 1049 639 796 695 1445 1368 430 139 984 988 750 1617 1151 554 83 288 605 791 1285 335 213 359 185 629 378 1074 190